Reforma copy/paste. Noul pachet de servicii medicale, amanat de patru ori, este similar cu cel propus de fostul ministruPrevious Article
Prof. dr. Margit Serban: „Nu pot sa-i spun copilului: «Ai cancer»“Next Article

BURNOUT SYNDROME – COMPARATIVE INVESTIGATION BETWEEN FAMILY PHYSICIANS WITH/WITHOUT BALINT TRAINING

Line Spacing+- AFont Size+- Print This Article
BURNOUT SYNDROME – COMPARATIVE INVESTIGATION BETWEEN FAMILY PHYSICIANS WITH/WITHOUT BALINT TRAINING

BURNOUT SYNDROME – COMPARATIVE INVESTIGATION BETWEEN FAMILY PHYSICIANS WITH/WITHOUT BALINT TRAINING

M.D. Albert VERESS, Ph.D. Valentin PANTEA

Abstract: the authors investigated the burnout situation at family physicians divided in two different groups, one with Balint training and other without Balint training. Thus it is confirmed once again the protective role of Balint practice during the medical activity for escape from the burnout problems.

Key words: family physicians, burnout, Balint training.

 

Introduction

 

         Freudenberger described the burnout syndrome (BS) in 1974. Initial this syndrome was described at the volunteers who activated for humanitarian organisation (1).

In 1983 Maslach define BS like a “syndrome of emotional exhaustion, depersonalisation and reduced personal accomplishment that can occur among individuals who do ‘people work’ of some kind” (2).

In 1994 Pines and Aaronson spread the application of BS to others workers and Karazman in 1998 utilised BS on the medical activities.

 

The aim of research

By this research we tried to find the influence of Balint group about the medical activity of family physicians.

 

Method and materials

 

For this research we used a questionnaire with 48 items linked in 12 themes. Every set by 4 questions corresponds of one problem that can appear in the medical activity: powerlessness, no information, conflict poor team work, overload, boredom, poor feed back, punishment, alienation, ambiguity, unrewarding and value conflict. Every item could be noted from 1 to 9 corresponding to frequency of appearing during the medical activity (1 – seldom and 9 – constant). By adding all the notes we obtained a score and by this we could identified the level of SB: 48 – 148 low level, 149 – 312 moderate level and 313 – 432 high level (3).

We applied this questionnaire to 2 groups: one made by 10 family physicians from Harghita County (which participated at Balint training) and 58 family physicians from Bihor County selected at random. We considered the second group as reference group because they didn’t participated at Balint training.

The composition of the Balint group was:

– 10% men and 90% women;

– 70% from village and 30% from city;

– 10% single, 10% divorced and 80% married;

– average age – 38 years;

– average length of service – 12 years;

– average number of patients – 1650.

Affirmative the length of service from Monday to Friday as 8 hours/day and 5 hours/week-end.

The composition of reference group was:

– 26% men and 74% women;

– 48% from village and 52% from city;

– 1,8% single, 10,3% divorced, 3,4 widower and 84,4% married;

– average age – 47 years;

– average length of service – 20 years;

– average number of patients – 1734.

Affirmative the length of service from Monday to Friday as 9 hours/day and 5 hours/week-end.

 

Results

 

The reference group had these scores: 13,8% low BS, 74,1% moderate BS and 12,1% high BS. The average score as 214.

For the Balint group scores was: 60% low BS, 40% moderate BS and the average score were 137.

In the reference group the highest notes was attributed to overload (average note 26,7), ambiguity  (average note 21,3) and conflict (average note 20,3). The lowest notes were: value conflict (average note 14,7), poor teamwork (average note 15,4) and no information (average note 15,6).

In Balint group the highest notes was attributed to ambiguity (average note 17,7), overload (average note 16,3) and unrewarding (average note 16,3). The lowest notes were: no information (average note 9,1), poor teamwork (average note 10,8) and value conflict (average note 11,6).

 

According to the gender of physicians by the comparison of the average score we obtained the next results:

 

Reference group

Balint group

% difference

M

209

126

39,7%

F

222

138

37,8%

 

Making a comparison between the average score according the place of office we obtained:

 

Reference group

Balint group

% difference

Village

196

169

13,8%

City

243

162

33.3%

 

For analyze of score according to the age of physicians we divided the groups in 3 subgroups: under 35 years, between 35 – 50 years and over 50 years. Thus we obtained:

 

Reference group

Balint group

% difference

< 35 years

206

162

16,5%

35 – 50 years

217

162

25,3%

> 50 years

227

112

50,7%

 

According by the civil status the comparison of the average score we obtained:

 

Reference group

Balint group

% difference

Married

226

175

22,5%

Single

222

127

42,8%

Divorced

182

112

38,5%

Widower

194

 

Discussions

 

The physicians from Balint group have scores of BS obvious better than the reference group made by physicians without Balint training. The difference between two groups vary between 13,8% and 50,7%, the average of difference was 32,1%. The average score of reference group was 214 comparison with 137 of Balint group (the percentage difference is 36,4%).

The teamwork and value conflict themes show a better approach of them who use the Balint method for patient – physician relation. At every categories of questionnaire (gender, civil status, place of office, age) the average scores shown a better value of physicians from Balint group than the reference group.

We can note that the problems shown at the reference group (overload, ambiguity and conflict) were spotlighted by other Romanian authors (4,5). These evidence confirmed the validity of reference group.

 

Conclusions

 

This research confirmed again, if there was necessary, the validity of observations others authors made by others groups. It’s obvious that the Balint training offer to the participants another mood of thinking in their activity and this special kind of approach save the mind and the spirit from the fail to sand bar of occupational and emotional exhaustion.

 

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

  1. Atance M. – Epidemiologic Aaspects of The Burnout Syndrome in Hospital Personnel , Revista Espaniol Saludad Publica, 1997, vol. 71, pages 293- 303;
  2. Alfried Lange – Burnout-Existential Meaning and Possibilities of Prevention, European Psychotherapy, 2003, vol. 4, no. 1, pages 107 – 121;
  3. Potter Beverly – Common Signs of Burnout, www.drpotter.com;
  4. Goron Maria – Suprasolicitarea medicului de familie, Viata Medicala, 2003, vol. 8, page 8;
  5. Popa-Nedelcu Maria – Sindromul Burnout in Romania, Viata Medicala, 2003, vol. 4, page 5.

 

 

BURNOUT QUESTIONARRY

 

Powerlessness

1. I can’t solve the problems assigned to me.

2. I am trapped in my job with no options.

3. I am unable to influence decisions that affect me.

4. I may be laid off and these is nothing I can do.

No Information

5. I am unclear about the responsibilities of my job.

6. I don’t have information I need to perform well.

7. People I work with don’t understand my role.

8. I don’t understand the purpose of my work.

Conflict

9.  I am caught in the middle.

10. I must satisfy conflicting demands.

11. I disagree with people at work.

12. I must violate procedures to get my job done.

Poor Team Work

13. Co-workers undermine me.

14. Management displays favoritism.

15. Office politics interfere with my doing my job.

16. People compete instead of cooperate.

Overload

17. My job interferes with my personal life.

18. I have too much to do into little time.

19. I must work on my own time.

20. My workload is overwhelming.

Boredom

21. I have too little to do.

22. I am overqualified for the work I actually do.

23. My work is not challenging.

24. The majority of my time is spent on routine tasks.

Poor Feedback

25. I don’t know what I’m doing right or wrong.

26. My supervisor doesn’t give feedback on my work.

27. I get information too late to act on it.

28. I don’t see the results of my work.

Punishment

29. My supervisor is critical.

30. Someone else gets credit for my work.

31. My work is unappreciated.

32. I get blamed for others’ mistakes.

Alienation

33. I am isolated form others.

34. I am just a cog in the organizational wheel.

35. I have little in common with people I work with.

36. I avoid telling people where I work or what I do.

Ambiguity

37. The rules are constantly changing.

38. I don’t know what is expected of me.

39. There is no relationship between performance and success.

40. Priorities I must meet are unclear.

Unrewarding

41. My work is not satisfying.

42. I have few real successes.

43. My career progress is not what I’d hoped.

44. I don’t get respect.

Values Conflict

45. I must compromise my values.

46. People disapprove of what I do.

47. I don’t believe in the company.

48. My heart is not in my work.

Citeste si

Esti epuizat profesional? Semne ca suferi de sindromul burnout

 

 

3 Comments

Leave Your Comment

<

*

Pregatirea cabinetelor pentru COVID 19

 

OMS România: Material – personalul medical.  Descarca documentul

OMS România: Materiale informative pentru locul de muncă:  Descarca documentele

Ministerul Sănătății: Măsuri  recomandate pentru populație (12 martie) – link

 

 

 

Video confecționare mască și vizor de protecție

Facebook

Aboneaza-te aici

Banner

INFORMATII UTILE

Reclamatii

 

 

 

STIRILE ZILEI

Umilinta de a profesa ca medic in Romania.

Umilinta de a profesa ca medic in Romania.   0

read more
Familia fostului ministru Sebastian Vlădescu deține firma care asigură mentenanța ventilatoarelor din TIR-ul ATI de la „Victor Babeș”

Familia fostului ministru Sebastian Vlădescu deține firma care asigură mentenanța ventilatoarelor din TIR-ul ATI de la „Victor Babeș”   0

read more
Medlife, despre răspunsul imun al organismului după vaccinarea anti-COVID-19: Post-vaccinare, riscul de infectare este foarte mic STUDIU

Medlife, despre răspunsul imun al organismului după vaccinarea anti-COVID-19: Post-vaccinare, riscul de infectare este foarte mic STUDIU   0

read more
Cum funcţionează cocktailul de anticorpi de la Regeneron şi cum ajută la prevenirea Covid-19

Cum funcţionează cocktailul de anticorpi de la Regeneron şi cum ajută la prevenirea Covid-19   0

read more
Oricine dorește se poate vaccina cu serul AstraZeneca, chiar dacă nu are programare. Precizări CNCAV

Oricine dorește se poate vaccina cu serul AstraZeneca, chiar dacă nu are programare. Precizări CNCAV   0

read more
Nefrectomii de înaltă complexitate realizate minim invaziv la Spitalul Clinic SANADOR

Nefrectomii de înaltă complexitate realizate minim invaziv la Spitalul Clinic SANADOR   0

read more
Adevărul Live de la 14.00: Sarcina în pandemie şi vaccinarea anti COVID-19

Adevărul Live de la 14.00: Sarcina în pandemie şi vaccinarea anti COVID-19   0

read more
Studiu: Tulpina britanică nu provoacă o formă de COVID-19 atât de gravă cum se credea

Studiu: Tulpina britanică nu provoacă o formă de COVID-19 atât de gravă cum se credea   0

read more
Anchetă la Spitalul din Târgu Neamț: un angajat s-a uitat la filme pentru adulți și a virusat calculatoarele

Anchetă la Spitalul din Târgu Neamț: un angajat s-a uitat la filme pentru adulți și a virusat calculatoarele   0

read more
Regeneron a solicitat aprobarea în SUA a tratamentului său cu anticorpi monoclonali pentru COVID-19, cu scop preventiv

Regeneron a solicitat aprobarea în SUA a tratamentului său cu anticorpi monoclonali pentru COVID-19, cu scop preventiv   0

read more
Raed Arafat: În România avem aproape 4.000 de paturi ATI, din care 1.532 pentru COVID. Azi am pierdut opt paturi

Raed Arafat: În România avem aproape 4.000 de paturi ATI, din care 1.532 pentru COVID. Azi am pierdut opt paturi   0

read more
DSU: Reprezentantul firmei distribuitoare a ventilatoarelor a refuzat intrarea în unitate

DSU: Reprezentantul firmei distribuitoare a ventilatoarelor a refuzat intrarea în unitate   0

read more
Trei pacienți au murit în unitatea mobilă ATI de la Spitalul Victor Babeș din cauza unei defecțiuni la instalația de oxigen

Trei pacienți au murit în unitatea mobilă ATI de la Spitalul Victor Babeș din cauza unei defecțiuni la instalația de oxigen   0

read more
Peste 62.800 de români au fost vaccinați în ultimele 24 de ore. S-au raportat 93 reacții adverse

Peste 62.800 de români au fost vaccinați în ultimele 24 de ore. S-au raportat 93 reacții adverse   0

read more
Tratamentul AstraZeneca împotriva diabetului nu este eficient pentru tratarea bolnavilor cu forme grave de COVID

Tratamentul AstraZeneca împotriva diabetului nu este eficient pentru tratarea bolnavilor cu forme grave de COVID   0

read more
Italia măreşte perioada dintre doze la vaccinurile Pfizer şi Moderna, de la 21 la 42 de zile

Italia măreşte perioada dintre doze la vaccinurile Pfizer şi Moderna, de la 21 la 42 de zile   0

read more
Tratamentul AstraZeneca împotriva diabetului nu este eficient pentru a trata pacienţii cu forme grave de COVID

Tratamentul AstraZeneca împotriva diabetului nu este eficient pentru a trata pacienţii cu forme grave de COVID   0

read more
Rată de infectare de 18% în ultimele 24 de ore. La terapie intensivă sunt 1.529 de pacienți

Rată de infectare de 18% în ultimele 24 de ore. La terapie intensivă sunt 1.529 de pacienți   0

read more
REPORTAJ. Două zile alături de un medic de terapie intensivă. Experiențele dramatice trăite într-o tură de 30 de ore de muncă

REPORTAJ. Două zile alături de un medic de terapie intensivă. Experiențele dramatice trăite într-o tură de 30 de ore de muncă   0

read more
Conform unui studiu, Marea Britanie atinge imunitatea de grup. Mircea Iliescu, genetician: „Nu înseamnă că ajungem la zero cazuri”

Conform unui studiu, Marea Britanie atinge imunitatea de grup. Mircea Iliescu, genetician: „Nu înseamnă că ajungem la zero cazuri”   0

read more
Marea Britanie ar atinge imunitatea de grup, conform unui studiu. Genetician: „Nu înseamnă că ajungem la zero cazuri”

Marea Britanie ar atinge imunitatea de grup, conform unui studiu. Genetician: „Nu înseamnă că ajungem la zero cazuri”   0

read more
Combinaţia de anticorpi a Regeneron reduce riscul îmbolnăvirii cu COVID-19 cu 81%

Combinaţia de anticorpi a Regeneron reduce riscul îmbolnăvirii cu COVID-19 cu 81%   0

read more
La cât timp se face rapelul dacă ne-am infectat între doze? Valeriu Gheorghiță: Vaccinarea previne formele severe

La cât timp se face rapelul dacă ne-am infectat între doze? Valeriu Gheorghiță: Vaccinarea previne formele severe   0

read more

Arhiva

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Seo wordpress plugin by www.seowizard.org.